Adaptogens for Stress: What the Evidence Shows and Who Should Be Careful

Adaptogens are herbs and mushrooms said to help the body cope with stress, and the best human evidence so far is for ashwagandha, taken short term. The class is not one thing, though. Each herb has its own research, its own dose and its own safety profile, and that matters most if you take medication, have a thyroid or autoimmune condition, or are pregnant. At Green Circle Wellness in Chicago, our practitioners have ample appointment time to look at your whole picture before anything is added to your routine.
TL;DR
“Adaptogen” is a label applied to many different herbs and mushrooms, so each one has to be judged on its own evidence, as the Merck Manual consumer guide explains.
Ashwagandha has the most consistent human data for perceived stress and cortisol, mostly over 6 to 12 weeks. Rhodiola has less research behind it.
Ashwagandha can cause drowsiness and stomach upset, rarely liver injury, and can interact with thyroid, diabetes, blood-pressure, immune-suppressing and sedative medicines.
Federal guidance advises people with autoimmune or thyroid disorders, and people who are pregnant or breastfeeding, to avoid ashwagandha.
A supplement label does not guarantee what is in the bottle, so quality and a clinician’s review come before the first dose.
Table of Contents
What adaptogens are, and why the word is slippery
The term describes plants and mushrooms that are believed to help the body respond to stress. Common examples include ashwagandha, rhodiola, Asian ginseng, Siberian ginseng, holy basil (tulsi), schisandra and reishi.

The Merck Manual makes a point that is easy to miss: the word is applied to a diverse group of foods and supplements, and each one needs to be evaluated separately. A result for one herb tells you little about another. The same logic applies to broad advice on types of stress management techniques: adaptogens are one tool among several, not a single treatment.
In practice, that means the useful question is not “do adaptogens work?” but “which herb, at what dose, for which kind of stress, in which person?”
What human studies have measured
A 2023 systematic review and meta-analysis by Tóth-Mészáros and colleagues looked at 25 trials of nine adaptogenic herbs in mentally stressed, otherwise healthy adults. The herbs included ashwagandha (Withania somnifera), Rhodiola rosea, Bacopa monnieri, Siberian ginseng, Panax ginseng and holy basil, among others.
The trials tracked two kinds of outcomes:
How people feel: perceived stress, anxiety, fatigue, sleep, attention and performance.
Lab markers: serum or salivary cortisol and ACTH, the pituitary hormone that signals the adrenal glands to make cortisol. A 2025 review by Llopis and colleagues describes both subjective and physiological measures being used in adaptogen research.
Results vary by herb and trial, and the more consistent stress-and-cortisol findings in those reviews belong to ashwagandha.
Ashwagandha: the best-studied option
The U.S. National Institutes of Health Office of Dietary Supplements reports on a 2021 systematic review of seven ashwagandha trials with 491 adults in India, who took preparations for 6 to 8 weeks. The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) says some ashwagandha preparations may help with stress, while evidence on anxiety is less clear.
One example from the 2025 Llopis review: in an eight-week randomized trial of 52 chronically stressed adults, ashwagandha was associated with serum cortisol falling 22.2% and perceived stress falling 32.7% by week 8.
Doses used in trials
The same NIH fact sheet reports that trial doses ranged from 240 to 1,250 mg per day of extract, or 12,000 mg per day of whole-root granules, equal to about 6,000 mg of root powder. Some studies found greater benefit at 500 to 600 mg per day than at lower amounts. Those are research doses for specific preparations. The right amount for you depends on your health, your medications and the product, which is why it belongs in a conversation with a clinician rather than on a label.
Adaptogens for cortisol: what the numbers say
Cortisol is the hormone most people associate with stress, so it is the marker most searched and most studied.
The Tóth-Mészáros review pooled five ashwagandha studies with 259 participants and found serum cortisol 3.27 μg/dL lower than placebo after 56 or 60 days (95% CI −4.62 to −1.92). A separate 2023 review by Della Porta and colleagues concluded that short-term ashwagandha may reduce cortisol in stressed people. It also found only nine eligible human studies, lasting 30 to 112 days, with different designs, formulations and doses. None assessed adrenal function or long-term effects.
Two practical points follow:
Cortisol is not the whole story. The Llopis review notes that subjective stress can improve without a measurable cortisol change. How you feel, sleep and function counts alongside the lab number.
A lower number is not automatically a better one. The Merck Manual cautions that stress-response chemicals such as cortisol also help the body defend itself, so lowering them is not automatically beneficial. That is why we prefer to interpret cortisol in context, with your symptoms, history and other biomarkers, rather than chase a single value.
Ashwagandha vs. rhodiola
People often ask which of the two to choose. Here is how they compare on the research.
Ashwagandha | Rhodiola | |
Plant part used | Root | Root |
Most studied for | Perceived stress, anxiety, sleep, cortisol | Fatigue and stress-related performance |
Volume of human research | Larger: 19 of 24 trials in one systematic review | Smaller: 5 of those 24 trials |
Typical trial length | 6 to 12 weeks | Often short |
Federal safety guidance | Detailed (NCCIH, OPSS, Merck Manual) | Less detailed |
That review pooled 24 randomized trials and noted that studies were short, small and varied in method. For a reader with high stress and poor sleep, ashwagandha has the deeper evidence base. For a reader whose main complaint is daytime fatigue under pressure, rhodiola is the herb studied for that. Neither is a substitute for finding out why your stress response is running high, which can involve sleep, thyroid function, blood sugar, hormones or gut health.
Side effects and who should avoid adaptogens
Most detailed safety guidance concerns ashwagandha, and it should not be assumed to describe every adaptogen. What the U.S. sources say:
Common effects: drowsiness and gastrointestinal symptoms. The Merck Manual Professional Edition also lists diarrhea, headache, nausea and sedation.
Rare but serious: liver injury has been reported, and thyroid effects are possible.
Duration: NCCIH says ashwagandha may be safe for short-term use up to three months, and there is not enough information on long-term safety. The Department of Defense’s Operation Supplement Safety program gives up to 12 weeks as the short-term window.
Medication interactions
Ashwagandha may interact with thyroid hormones and with medicines for diabetes, high blood pressure, immune suppression, sedation and seizures. The Merck Manual lists thyroid hormones and antihyperglycemic, antihypertensive, immunosuppressant and sedative medicines. If you take any of these, talk with your prescriber before starting.
Who should avoid it
NCCIH advises avoiding ashwagandha during pregnancy, with autoimmune or thyroid disorders, and before surgery, and not using it while breastfeeding. OPSS adds liver disease and hormone-sensitive prostate cancer to the list of situations where it may be unsuitable.
If you have an autoimmune condition, this is a conversation for your physician before any adaptogen. Stop and call your doctor if you develop symptoms such as persistent nausea, unusual fatigue, itching or yellowing of the skin or eyes while taking a supplement.
Choosing a product: what the label cannot tell you
OPSS points out that ingredients and amounts in a supplement cannot be confirmed without laboratory testing, and suggests looking for independent third-party evaluation. This matters because trial results come from specific extracts at specific doses. A retail capsule may differ from the product that was studied.
Before you buy anything, run through this short list:
Does the label name the plant part and the extract, not just “proprietary blend”?
Is there independent third-party testing?
Does the dose sit in the range studied for that herb?
Have you cleared it against your medications and conditions with a clinician?
Do you have a stop date, so you can judge whether it helped?
Before you reach for an herb: look at what is driving the stress
Adaptogens address how the body responds to stress. They do not tell you why your response is strained. Poor sleep, thyroid imbalance, blood sugar swings, hormone changes, nutrient gaps and gut inflammation can all feel like “stress.” Treating the symptom without checking these can leave the cause in place.
This is where an integrative evaluation helps. Our functional medicine approach looks at which tests actually change care, and our practitioners work with your history rather than a generic protocol. Related pieces on microbiome testing and Vitamin D3 and K2 testing before dosing show the same principle: measure first, then decide.
How we think about adaptogens at Green Circle
Patients usually come to us after trying something on their own. A bottle of ashwagandha, a mushroom blend, a stack of supplements. What they rarely have is a clear reason for choosing it. Our view is simple. Stress has causes, and finding them is the first job. That takes time, which is why our appointments are built to give you ample time with a practitioner, and why our team works across specialties to put one plan together instead of several unconnected ones. For people with chronic conditions, autoimmune disease or a medication list, the question is never only “is this herb popular?” It is “is this right for this person, now?” We would rather answer that with personalized testing and a conversation than with a label. Dina
Work with a clinician on a stress plan
If you live in Chicago, or in Illinois and prefer a virtual consult, we can help you sort out what is driving your stress and whether any supplement belongs in your plan. Our nutritional consultations and functional medicine visits are built around personalized testing and tailored treatment plans that address root causes, not just symptoms.

You can see everything we offer, from hormone therapy to gut flora optimization, on our services page, or read how we work on our approach page.
FAQ
Do adaptogens really lower stress?
Some do, in some people. The strongest human data is for short-term ashwagandha, where trials report lower perceived stress and, in pooled analyses, lower serum cortisol versus placebo. Evidence for other adaptogens is smaller, and each herb must be judged on its own.
Are adaptogens safe to take every day?
Not necessarily without limits. NCCIH says ashwagandha may be safe for up to three months, and long-term safety is not established. Side effects include drowsiness and stomach upset, and rare liver injury has been reported. Review any daily use with a clinician, especially if you take medication.
Can I take adaptogens with an autoimmune condition?
NCCIH advises avoiding ashwagandha if you have an autoimmune or thyroid disorder. Do not start any adaptogen without talking to your physician first. Safety data for other adaptogens in autoimmune disease is limited, so individual review matters.
Should I test my cortisol before starting an adaptogen?
A cortisol result is one data point, and research shows how you feel can improve without a measurable cortisol change. A clinician can decide whether testing makes sense alongside your symptoms, sleep, thyroid and other markers.
Sources
The effect of adaptogenic plants on stress: a systematic review and meta-analysis
The Effects of Psychobiotics and Adaptogens on the Human Stress Response, 2025
Effects of Withania somnifera on Cortisol Levels, 2023 review
Clinical evidence for the adaptogenic effects of Withania somnifera and Rhodiola
Ashwagandha in Dietary Supplement Products, Operation Supplement Safety
Recommended
This article is for education only and is not medical advice.



Comments